Question: Tonight’s winner will hoist the Paul Bunyan Trophy, but in 1958, the trophy had a strange problem when the game ended in a 12-12 tie. What happened to it?

Answer: Nobody wanted it. The heavily favored Spartans were too embarrassed by the tie to accept the trophy, and the Wolverines refused to take it, too. Michigan State finally relented and kept it in East Lansing. The 9-foot prize, a 4-foot carving of the legendary lumberjack on a 5-foot base, wasn’t exactly beloved in its early years.